Is The Oracle Losing His Touch?
Published on Wednesday, 09 May 2012 00:00 Written by Todd Shriber
Legendary value investor Warren Buffett didn’t become legendary by lagging the S&P 500 on a regular basis, but that’s exactly what Berkshire Hathaway’s (NYSE: BRK-A, BRK-B) equity portfolio has doe for the past three years. Before rushing to criticize Buffett, investors should note that the SPDR S&P 500 is up 55.31% in the past three years and topping that performance would be hard for probably 80% or more of the fund managers out there.
Then again, investors have come to expect more from Buffett. The Oracle of Omaha can move almost any stock he so chooses and thousands of investors, both professional and retail, have been known to mimic Berkshire’s equity portfolio to a tee.
That might be part of the problem. Berkshire’s equity positions are widely known, but not until after the company makes it purchases. Then investors that live and die by Buffett’s every move and come in and by the same stocks. That’s good for Buffett, but it’s not always good for the investors attempting to establish their own "baby Berkshires."
It’s easy to see why Berkshire’s equity portfolio may have lagged the broader market over the past three years. While the firm’s large positions in financial services stocks such as American Express (NYSE: AXP), U.S. Bancorp (NYSE: USB) and Wells Fargo (NYSE: WFC) have helped, most of the firm’s other positions are decidedly low beta, such as Coca-Cola (NYSE: KO) and Procter & Gamble (NYSE: PG).
Over the past three years, one of the best-performing select sector SPDRs has been the Technology Select Sector SPDR (NYSE: XLK), but until late 2011, Buffett didn’t own any tech stocks. Energy stocks were also bigger winners from the March 2009 bottom through a good part of 2011, but Berkshire only held token positions in two oil stocks, Exxon Mobil (NYSE: XOM), which has been eliminated from the portfolio, and ConocoPhillips (NYSE: COP).
Zeroing in on some of Berkshire’s holdings and how they’ve performed recently sheds even more light on why the firm’s stock investments have failed to outpace the broader market. In the past three months, Gannett (NYSE: GCI) and rival Washington Post (NYSE: WPO) have both incurred double-digit losses. Costco (NASDAQ: COST) has lost almost 7% in that time while Moody’s (NYSE: MCO) has slid nearly 8%.
Procter & Gamble has slid nearly 5% over the past 90 days and over that time horizon, 10 of Berkshire’s other stock investments have lost 2% or more and that’s not including the names already mentioned.
This may really depress those that revere Buffett so much: He has also lagged the Vanguard Total Stock Market ETF (NYSE: VTI) over the past three years meaning investors could have used a passively managed product with fees of 0.06% and done better than one of the most successful investors of all time.
- U.S. Bancorp Is Close to its 50 and 200 Day Moving Averages
- Critical Alerts For Coca Cola, Fastenal, Akamai Technologies, ANSYS, and Portfolio Recovery Associates Released By InvestorsObserver
- The Range Is Tightening in Procter
- TradersHuddle Mid-day Update: Dow Jones Lower Top Performers: AXP, PG, WMT
- Above Resistance: U.S. Bancorp
- Critical Alerts For American Express, Mosaic, Blackstone Group, Molycorp, and Solar City Released By InvestorsObserver
- The Range Is Tightening in U.S. Bancorp
- Top Performing Dow Component: Pfizer
- Procter Is in a Very Tight Range
- Trading Idea: Momentum Building in U.S. Bancorp
Related Partner Headlines
- WalMart May Still Get Its Bank: Street Whispers - TheStreet.com
- U.S. Bancorp Stock Buy Recommendation Reiterated (USB) - TheStreet.com
- Local Businesses Take on Big-Box Retailers - TheStreet.com
- U.S. Bancorp (USB): Today's Featured Banking Winner - TheStreet.com
- New York Blasts Wells Fargo's Sandy Stall - TheStreet.com
- 3 Things You Should Know About Small Business: Nov. 16 - TheStreet.com
- Coca-Cola Co (KO): Today's Featured Food & Beverage Winner - TheStreet.com
- American Express Co (AXP): Today's Featured Real Estate Laggard - TheStreet.com
- Wells Fargo & Co (WFC): Today's Featured Financial Laggard - TheStreet.com
- U.S. Bank Healthcare Closes $931 Million in Credit Facilities for Trinity Health System - Benzinga
Latest Partner Headlines
Dow Today: Verizon Communications (VZ) Higher - TheStreet.com
Separating the Bargains From the Busts - TheStreet.com
Cramer Quick Take: The 60-Inch TV Will Be Key This Holiday - TheStreet.com
Cramer Quick Take: Cisco Wins If Fiscal Cliff Is Resolved - TheStreet.com
Gap Up and Sit - TheStreet.com
Apple, Intel, MicroStrategy: Tech Winners & Losers - TheStreet.com
Windows 8 PC Sales Disappointing: Report - TheStreet.com
Cramer Quick Take: Buy Home Depot and Lowe's - TheStreet.com
Dow JonesCompany ID [INDEXDJX:.DJI] Last trade:15,354.40 Trade time:4:40PM EDT Value change:▲121.18 (0.80%)
S&P 500Company ID [INDEXSP:.INX] Last trade:1,667.47 Trade time:4:39PM EDT Value change:▲17.00 (1.03%)
NASDAQCompany ID [INDEXNASDAQ:.IXIC] Last trade:3,498.97 Trade time:5:15PM EDT Value change:0.00 (0.00%)
In The Wires
IBM Analytics Help Arad Group Manage Big Data for Water Meter Solutions
Ford Fusion Energi Earns Top Vehicle Safety Rating from NHTSA
Live Nation Further Expands Presence In Asia, Forms Joint Venture With Lushington
China Xiniya Fashion Limited Reports 2013 First Quarter Financial Results
The "17 Cheat Foods That Burn Fat" Review and Diet Plan Secrets Revealed by Daily Gossip
Intesa, Unicredit hurt by Italian trials and tribulations according to SNL Financial's recent report
Summit Medical Group Welcomes the Center for Orthopedic Care
Used Ford 5R44E Transmission Reduced in Price Online at GotTransmissions.com